More on Gaither’s Best Ofs

So now I’ve seen three or four of these Homecoming Best Of features on a single Homecoming artist (Anthony Burger, Lynda Randall, and George Younce among them), I’m surprised at the general low quality of production. I’ve seen dentist office waiting rooms with better lighting and décor than the settings for the AB and LR interviews and the interviews themselves contributed very little to a better sense of the artist. I should probably draw a distinction between tribute albums (post-mortems) and Best Ofs (which are generally for the living) and maybe another cross section would slice out personalities (Randall) vs Big Stars (AB and Younce). But even then there are common problems across all the albums that come down to one version or another of the problem I identified with George Younce’s tribute: they’re a little boring and pretty much fail to capture the very individuality and scope of the talent they attempt to celebrate (see here). All that said, I assume these things are gold mines, right?

Email this Post

Comments

  1. RF wrote:

    If you want to know the true source of all these “Best of” DVDs, check out gaither.com. All those folks want a “best of” collection on every one of the Gakither bunch. Production is usually not up to their usual excellent, but like a documentary, nice to put in the collection.

  2. Jim E. Davis wrote:

    I found an exception with the cover of Guy Penrod. Hopping on the back of an old truck and meandering through his country estate loaded with cattle, barns and plenty of kids was fascinating and kept my attention all the way through. This was an honest window into his life that I think a high percentage of people would love to peer through if they had the chance. It beats wallpaper and cluttered bookcases anyday!

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked * Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.

*

*