OT: Sandi Patty, The CCM Judy Garland

Via Martin Roth (seriously, give this man an award for finding the most fascinating mainstream media coverage of Christian music, and then withhold it from him until he consistently puts permalinks on his posts), a brave Washington Blade story that dares to talk about something that anyone paying attention has known for years but no one wants to admit. Sandi Patty has a huge following among gay men.

Why? The story takes a not-half-bad stab at it, and you can read that for yourself (or not - if this isn’t your bag, don’t say you weren’t warned). But besides oddly implying that gay people don’t go to church (which, no matter your feelings on the issue, is just plain counterfactual) - or on second thought, maybe the article is suggesting that music of the sort Patty makes is church enough for some people - one thing noticeably absent from the story’s analysis was any mention of the element of campiness in Patty’s persona and performance and its role in her appeal to gay men. Like showtunes and some of the outsized personalities of many charismatic televangelicals and the hyper-stylized, over-the-top persona of a Cher or a Madonna or a Judy Garland or, even - yes - a Vestal Goodman (all with long-established followings among gay guys), there’s something campy - that is exagerrated and theatrical and a touch ironic or more knowing than we think - about Sandi Patty’s stage presence (all those operatic flourishes she uses and the bedazzling costumes and the arrangements and choreography of many of her songs and performances taken, ehrm, straight out of Broadway).

It would take (and has taken) many a PhD dissertation and several books to get into the connection between homosexuality, camp, and music (though the essayist Richard Rodriguez may be on to something when he suggests, in his memoir Brown: The Last Discovery of America, that the exaggeration and role-playing that Broadway musicals rely on and other music that borrows from Broadway employs often feel like the most authentic way for socially marginalized people - not just gay people but many women, and artistic or eccentric types - to express themselves). But this Blade piece not only reminds us that many of our favorite Christian (including southern gospel) artists rely on stage personae that are to some extent carefully crafted constructs (which is, as I’ve said before, no reason at all to think the music is any less “real” or “authentic”). The story also does a decent job of capturing the sometimes vertiginous intersection of religion and sexuality that can happen when we’re not looking - or pretending we’re not to, anyway.

Email this Post

Comments

  1. Daniel J. Mount wrote:

    Ugh.

  2. jojo wrote:

    What a coincidence Mr. Mount. The same thing comes to my mind when I read your posts.

  3. Daniel J. Mount wrote:

    Thank you. (?)

  4. Scott wrote:

    Check out this link. When I talked to Tish several years ago, she told me she patterned a good bit of her stage personna off Vestal.

    http://www.whosoever.org/Issue6/gospelgirls.htmlhttp://www.whosoever.org/Issue6/gospelgirls.html

  5. Scott wrote:

    Somehow that link is repeated twice.

    Here it is again:

    http://www.whosoever.org/Issue6/gospelgirls.html

    I know everyone is just clamouring to read it. :-)

  6. CVH wrote:

    There’s no doubt that there are gays working in SG and CCM, including arrangers and orchestrators. For the record, I’ve long ago decided that the quality of work is more important than the orientation. That whole question/issue is interesting but not something that will probably ever be resolved, at least as far as the business goes, so I have little interest in focusing on it.

    Sandi’s flourished, overembellished arrangements have often had that ‘over the top’ characteristic associated with the campy gay lifestyle. There are times when restraint is shown and a really tasteful arrangement emerges; other times her charts are SO exaggerated that you have to wonder…or not.

    She’s always been an awesome talent and no matter what personal issues she’s had to work through in her life, she remains one of the best. But sometimes I wish there was just a little less bombast and a little more pure artistry shining through.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked * Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.

*

*