Dove context

Reader DA writes to rightly remind us that there IS a nasty and often overlooked history of outright vote-buying in sg for Dove Awards. I speak of course of the infamous James Blackwood episode of 1971. The Blackwoods were accused of aggressively recruiting votes for themselves and “tainting the process” by giving out ballots with the Blackwoods’ name already filled in and in some cases including free memberships to GMA and other gifts. As James Goff writes, “no specific bylaw of the organization had been broken,” but “the tractic created an industrywide concern over” voting improprieties. Blackwood apologized (though notably only “For what I consider unethical solicitation of votes by members of our organization,” - not anything he himself personally did … that’s my emphasis in the quote), and the awards were nullified anyway.

The whole ordeal proceeded in a code of ethics but no real substantive changes to the process, which seems pretty clearly to remain vulnerable to being gamed. More to the point though, I suspect that Blackwood simply was the first to get caught doing something that was shocking the first time but becomes less so as we desensitize ourselves to the realities of corruption among the saints. Which is to say, Blackwood’s Get Out The Vote shenanigans today probably wouldn’t have caused nearly as much of a stir.

(A sidenote: it’s interesting that Blackwood’s Dove buying scandal gets so little attention these days in the collective memory of sg, and elsewhere too … Blackwood’s wikipedia entry makes a big stink about how many Dove Awards he won and yet studiously ignores his vote-buying scandal. I wonder if this isn’t the case because few people want to remind each other that one of gospel music’s patriachs was involved in such unseemly mucking about in the sludge of raw self-aggrandizement).

In the Young Harmony bit below, I linked to a post of mine from a few years back about how the Doves work. But just in case you missed it (and some people obviously did), here it is again. Here also is some historical context on the chilly relationship between sg and GMA.

Email this Post


  1. DE wrote:

    Well if anyone looks back…. Ed Leonard became a board member and they bought a TON of votes….every year since they have had the most noms and wins of any label….

  2. DM wrote:

    Remember, that is why London Paris left the Blackwoods.

  3. dlbgus wrote:

    DM - fill me in. Why DID London Paris leave the Blackwoods?

  4. Jim2 wrote:

    Besides Crabb Family and Lewis Family, what Dove wins are you talking about? OK, Brian Free tied with Crabbs last year, but who’s to argue that those Dove’s are not about talent? Who did you think should have beat any of those groups? Sometimes the people with the clout are also the best out there, IMO.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked * Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.